Why Didn’t My Mortgage Payment Go Down After I Paid Extra?

Why Didn’t My Mortgage Payment Go Down After I Paid Extra?

Source: Pexels

If you are lucky enough to get some unexpected money, you may want to use it to lower your mortgage. After all, it makes sense to know that you owe less on your home. So, you put in $20,000. Job done.

But when your next mortgage statement arrives, you cannot understand why the amount due is still the same. How can that be?

Put simply, an extra mortgage payment may help to lessen the amount that you owe on your home but does not mean that it is automatically going to lessen your monthly installments.

This is because when you have a fixed-rate mortgage, your lender will often keep your payments the same and automatically use the extra money to help you pay your loan off sooner.

mortgage
Source: Unsplash

Where Did Your Extra Money Go?

Let us say for example that you owe $200,000 on your home. Your interest rate is fixed at 4%, and you have about 25 years left on your mortgage. If this were the case, your monthly payment for both the loan and the interest would be approximately $1,056 per month.

When you pay an extra $20,000 into your mortgage and mark it as a payment to principal, the mortgage servicer will allocate this money toward your principal, which is the amount of money you still owe. This does not include interest.

The total balance of your mortgage will drop from $200,000 to $180,000, but your monthly installment will stay at $1,056.

You may owe less on your home, but you still have to make the same payment, so where exactly is the benefit?

The simple answer is that the benefit lies in the fact that the extra money that you put into your mortgage goes towards paying down the balance.

This means that you could end up paying off your mortgage in 21 years instead of 25 years, and you would be saving about $30,200 in interest without making any more extra payments.

This is because the $20,000 that you put in has made a massive difference. You may not see a smaller bill next month, but you will see the benefits in the amount of time and interest left on your loan.

If, however, you are set on paying smaller monthly installments, it is a good idea to ask your lender about a mortgage recast.

What Is a Mortgage Recast?

A mortgage recast is when your lender takes the new lower mortgage balance as well as the time that you have left to repay the loan to recalculate your monthly payment. The only thing is that your interest rate and original loan end date will stay the same.

Here is how it works. After you have paid the extra $20,000 toward your mortgage, your balance will be $180,000. If your lender approves a recast on the loan, then your monthly payment would go from $1,056 to about $950 per month. This is a savings of around $106 every month.

You will, however, continue to pay your mortgage for the full 25 years instead of finishing four years earlier, but you would be saving about $11,700 in interest compared to if you had made no extra payment.

How Do You Ask Your Lender for a Recast?

You should be able to find your servicer’s contact details on your latest statement.

This is what you need to ask them:

  • Am I able to recast my mortgage? Not all lenders give you this option. However, many conventional loans have this option. Loans backed by government programs, such as FHA, VA and USDA loans, cannot be recast.
  • How much will I need to pay? This all depends on the lender. Some have no minimum requirement, although others could ask for $5,000, $10,000 or more.
  • Are there fees involved? Most lenders won’t charge more than a few hundred dollars.
  • When does this come into effect? It can take between 30 and 90 days.

It is important to make sure that your mortgage account is up to date, as your lender will check this. However, in most cases there is no credit check needed, so your credit score should not be affected.

Work Out What a Recast Would Save You

Arcanomy’s free mortgage recast calculator allows you to enter your current balance, the interest rate that you currently pay, the number of years left on your loan, and the amount that you want to pay into your mortgage, so you can see what your own lump sum would do.

The calculator works by calculating the estimated new monthly payment and savings on interest to show you how a recast would compare to keeping your current payment.

If, however, you have already paid the amount into your mortgage, then you will have to add the extra payment to your current balance and type in the lump sum separately.

It is important to use the original loan end date when you count the years left. The calculator only looks at the principal and interest and does not include any lender fee.

Why Your Mortgage Bill May Still Change

Sometimes, your mortgage payment may not drop to the amount that you had thought it would. This is because a recast only lowers the principal and interest portion of your monthly amount and does not affect homeowners’ insurance and property taxes.

Before You Send Another Extra Payment

Before you pay all of your money into your mortgage account you must make sure that you have enough put away for other expenses such as household emergencies, repairs, and unexpected bills as it can be hard to get that money back.

If you are planning to sell your home in a few years, paying for a recast may not be worth it, and if you want to become mortgage-free sooner then asking for a recast may not be worth it.

You need to make your choice according to what is going to work best for your household and your circumstances. If you want to pay off your mortgage sooner, it is better to keep your monthly installment as it is.

If, however, you would like to have a bit more money in your bank account at the end of the month, it may be wise to ask your servicer about a recast. Try to do this before sending an extra payment so that you know exactly what your options are. If you have already sent it, call your servicer and ask whether that payment can still count toward a recast, and ask for the answers in writing.


As Seen In